Sizing a tank: first-hour rating
The U.S. Department of Energy says to size a storage water heater by its first-hour rating (FHR): how many gallons of hot water it can supply in an hour, starting with a full tank. It's on the EnergyGuide label. Pick a model whose FHR at least matches your peak-hour demand.
| Use | Gallons per use (DOE worksheet) |
|---|---|
| Shower | 20 |
| Shaving (0.05 gal per minute) | 2 |
| Hand dishwashing or food prep (2 gal per minute) | 4 (see note) |
| Automatic dishwasher | 7 |
| Clothes washer, top-loader | 25 |
| Clothes washer, front-loader (H-axis) | 15 |
Note: DOE's current worksheet lists 3 gallons for hand dishwashing, but its own example (3 showers, 1 shave and 1 hand dishwashing) totals 66 gallons, which counts 4. This calculator uses 4 so it matches that total; the difference is 1 gallon.
Worked example (tank)
DOE's example household has 3 showers, 1 shave and 1 hand dishwashing in its busiest hour: 3 × 20 + 2 + 4 = 66 gallons. It needs a water heater with a first-hour rating of 66 gallons or more. Tank size alone isn't the FHR, so compare the rating on the label, not just the gallons.
Sizing a tankless heater: flow and temperature rise
Tankless (demand) water heaters are rated by the temperature rise they can deliver at a given flow rate. Add up the flow of everything that might run at once, then work out the rise:
Temperature rise = wanted temperature − incoming water temperature
Heat output ≈ GPM × rise × 500 BTU/h (8.33 lb per gallon × 60 minutes)
kW = BTU/h ÷ 3,412
Worked example (tankless)
DOE's example: a 0.75 GPM faucet and a 2.5 GPM shower head at once is 3.25 GPM. With 50 °F incoming water and 120 °F wanted, the rise is 70 °F. The heat needed is about 3.25 × 70 × 500 = 113,750 BTU/h of output, or 113,750 ÷ 3,412 = 33.3 kW. (The calculator uses the more exact 8.33 lb per gallon × 60 = 499.8 in place of 500, which gives 113,705, shown rounded as about 113,700 BTU/h.) Look for a model rated for a 70 °F rise at 3.25 GPM or more. DOE notes that gas models are typically rated for a 70 °F rise at about 5 GPM, and electric models at about 2 GPM.
Limitations
- Groundwater temperature varies by region and season. If you don't know yours, DOE suggests assuming 50 °F; in northern winters it can be colder, so a tankless heater delivers less flow.
- Low-flow fixtures help. Efficient shower heads and washers lower both peak-hour demand and the GPM needed.
- Hotter isn't always better. Dishwashers without a booster may want 140 °F (a 90 °F rise), but higher temperatures raise the risk of scalding.
- Fuel and venting matter as much as size: gas line size, venting and electrical capacity can limit which models fit.